The 2025 PML rookie quarterback class has brought a wide range of performances through the first three weeks of the season. Some quarterbacks were expected to make an immediate impact due to their draft pedigree, while others were less heralded but have already managed to surprise. In this article, we’ll rank and analyze all 17 rookie quarterbacks, evaluating their on-field stats, team context, and overall performance. The rankings will reflect both individual stats and the circumstances of their play, such as team success, protection, and responsibility.
1. Connor Weigman – Round 1, Pick 18, Saints
49/75, 771 yards, 8 TD, 6 INT, 2 sacks, 16 rush yards – 3 starts (3-0)
Weigman has been the most impressive rookie so far, leading the Saints to an undefeated 3-0 start. His stats show a strong command of the offense, with 8 touchdowns balanced against 6 interceptions. Though the interceptions are high, he has shown resilience in bouncing back from mistakes, making him the most effective rookie in terms of wins. He’s been well-protected with only 2 sacks, allowing him to distribute the ball effectively, while adding just enough mobility to escape pressure. Despite the turnovers, Weigman’s success as a team leader elevates him to the top of this list. He’s made a huge impact for New Orleans in a short time.
2. Drew Allar – Round 3, Pick 20, Vikings
52/71, 752 yards, 8 TD, 2 INT, 2 sacks, 7 rush yards, 1 rush TD – 2 starts (1-1)
Allar has made a very strong case through two starts, particularly with his touchdown-to-interception ratio of 8:2, showing excellent decision-making for a third-round pick. His accuracy is notable, completing 73.2% of his passes. The Vikings have kept him well-protected (only 2 sacks), and while his rushing stats are minimal, his ability to score on the ground adds another layer to his game. Allar’s poised play and strong stats, especially given his draft position, make him one of the standout rookies, although after Ryan Tannehill’s performance last season, it may just be Minnesota.
3. Jalen Milroe – Round 1, Pick 1, Jets
65/93, 1123 yards, 7 TD, 6 INT, 5 sacks, 117 rush yards, 3 rush TD, 3 fumbles – 3 starts (2-1)
The number one overall pick, Milroe has shown flashes of brilliance, particularly as a dual-threat quarterback. His 1123 passing yards lead all rookies, and he’s added another 117 yards and 3 touchdowns on the ground. However, his 6 interceptions and 3 fumbles indicate ball security issues that have held him back slightly. Milroe’s ability to produce both in the air and on the ground is undeniable, but his mistakes make him less consistent than the top two. Still, his ceiling remains sky-high, and he’s already helped lead the Jets to a 2-1 record.
4. Kurtis Rourke – Round 4, Pick 28, Bucs
43/78, 690 yards, 7 TD, 5 INT, 4 sacks, 29 rush yards, 2 rush TD – 3 starts (3-0)
Rourke has been a pleasant surprise for the Bucs, starting 3-0 and showing a knack for getting into the end zone. His passing stats are solid, and his ability to rush for two touchdowns adds versatility to his game. The 5 interceptions are a blemish, but his overall play and leadership have kept his team undefeated. Rourke’s ability to score both through the air and on the ground elevates him to this spot, especially given his low draft position.
5. Cam Ward – Round 1, Pick 3, Browns
22/26, 344 yards, 4 TD, 1 INT, 3 sacks, 57 rush yards, 1 fumble – 1 start (1-0)
Ward has only started one game, but what a game it was. His completion percentage (84.6%) and efficiency in throwing 4 touchdowns to just 1 interception are impressive, albeit from a small sample size. He also showed off his mobility with 57 rushing yards. While we haven’t seen much of Ward yet, his lone start was so efficient that he’s hard to ignore in these rankings. The challenge for him will be maintaining that level of play over a larger stretch of games. Cleveland looked good without Ward in weeks 1 and 2, but they looked special with him in week 3.
6. KJ Jefferson – Round 2, Pick 20, Giants
51/104, 1206 yards, 11 TD, 12 INT, 14 sacks, 85 rush yards, 1 rush TD, 2 fumbles – 3 starts (0-3)
Jefferson’s stat line is a rollercoaster. On the one hand, he leads all rookies in passing yards and touchdowns, but his 12 interceptions are the most glaring issue. Adding in 14 sacks and 2 fumbles, Jefferson’s lack of protection and turnover-prone style have cost the Giants games. Despite the team’s 0-3 record, he’s shown flashes of brilliance, particularly in his ability to stretch the field. If he can cut down on mistakes, he has the tools to be successful.
7. Shedeur Sanders – Round 1, Pick 10, Dolphins
39/64, 764 yards, 7 TD, 8 INT, 2 sacks, 48 rush yards, 1 rush TD – 2 starts (1-1)
Sanders has had a rocky start to his career, with 8 interceptions in just two starts overshadowing his otherwise solid numbers. He has shown the ability to make plays, both as a passer and a runner, but his tendency to turn the ball over has held him back. Despite this, his potential is clear, and with some adjustments, he could quickly climb this list.
8. Carson Beck – Round 4, Pick 4, Falcons
43/89, 724 yards, 7 TD, 11 INT, 11 sacks – 3 starts (0-3)
Beck’s performance has been up and down through his first three starts. His 11 interceptions are a huge concern, and he’s been sacked 11 times, a sign of either poor protection or holding onto the ball too long. However, his 7 touchdowns show he can make plays when given the chance. The Falcons’ 0-3 start reflects his struggles, but he has the arm talent to turn things around if he can clean up the turnovers.
9. Quinn Ewers – Round 1, Pick 15, Rams
14/24, 157 yards, 1 TD, 3 INT, 3 sacks, 11 rush yards – 1 start (1-0)
Ewers didn’t put up huge numbers in his lone start, but he led the Rams to a victory. His 3 interceptions in just 24 attempts are concerning, but his ability to manage the game when it mattered most is notable. As he gains more experience, it will be interesting to see if he can iron out his decision-making and become a more consistent starter.
10. Will Rogers – Undrafted, Broncos
17/26, 193 yards, 2 TD, 3 INT, 2 sacks, 29 rush yards, 1 rush TD – 0 starts
Rogers has come in as a backup for the Broncos and made some plays, but his 3 interceptions in just 26 attempts show that he’s still adjusting to the speed of the NFL. His rushing touchdown adds some intrigue to his game, and his ability to step in as an undrafted player deserves recognition, even if the results have been mixed.
11. Riley Leonard – Round 6, Pick 20, Bills
13/23, 177 yards, 1 TD, 0 INT, 1 sack, 13 rush yards – 0 starts
Leonard hasn’t had much of a chance to shine yet, but in his limited action, he’s been efficient. His lone touchdown and lack of interceptions are promising, but he’s not yet been tested in a full game setting. For now, he remains a backup with potential.
12. Miller Moss – Round 7, Pick 23, Lions
6/12, 129 yards, 2 TD, 2 INT, 1 sack, -12 rush yards – 0 starts
Moss has seen the field in limited action, throwing two touchdowns but also two interceptions. His negative rushing yards come purely from kneeldowns, but his ability to score when given the opportunity keeps him from dropping too far down the list.
13. Gavin Wimsatt – Round 6, Pick 14, Packers
10/19, 78 yards, 1 TD, 2 INT, 13 rush yards – 0 starts
Wimsatt has had limited opportunities but hasn’t done much to impress so far. His 2 interceptions in just 19 attempts suggest he’s still adjusting to the NFL game. As a sixth-round pick, he’s likely viewed as a developmental player for the Packers.
14. Jaxson Dart – Round 5, Pick 11, Ravens
5/17, 93 yards, 2 INT, 4 sacks – 0 starts
Dart’s brief appearances have been rough, with 2 interceptions and 4 sacks in just 17 pass attempts. His struggles under pressure have been evident, and he’s yet to show much promise as a backup for the Ravens.
15. Cam Rising – Undrafted, Seahawks
2/2, 26 yards – 0 starts
Rising has seen very limited action, completing both of his pass attempts for 26 yards. While it’s a small sample size, he hasn’t made any mistakes in his brief appearances. As an undrafted free agent, he is likely deep on the Seahawks’ depth chart, and we haven’t yet seen enough of him to make a definitive assessment. For now, he remains a developmental player who will need more opportunities to prove his worth.
16. Taylen Green – Round 3, Pick 22, Raiders
1/1, -5 yards, 8 rush yards – 0 starts
Green has been used sparingly in a backup role, completing his only pass for negative yardage and rushing for 8 yards. There isn’t much to evaluate here, as he’s yet to get significant playing time. His draft position suggests the Raiders see potential in him, but for now, his impact has been negligible, and he remains a developmental project.
17. Dillon Gabriel – Round 4, Pick 17, Colts
1/3, 11 yards, 1 INT – 0 starts
Gabriel’s limited action has been concerning, as he threw an interception in his only meaningful opportunity. With just three pass attempts and minimal yardage, there’s little to be optimistic about so far. As a fourth-round pick, the Colts may have hoped for more, but Gabriel’s start has been shaky, and he’ll need to improve significantly to earn more chances.
The 2025 rookie quarterback class has delivered a range of performances, with some surprising breakout stars and others struggling to adapt to the pros. Connor Weigman’s undefeated start and Drew Allar’s efficiency make them the standouts through the first three weeks, while top picks like Jalen Milroe and Cam Ward have shown flashes of brilliance but it just isn’t a large enough sample size. Further down the list, quarterbacks like KJ Jefferson and Shedeur Sanders have potential but must overcome turnovers and inconsistency. As the season progresses, we’ll see if these young quarterbacks can continue to develop and elevate their teams or fall behind in the ever-competitive PML landscape.
