The results are in from the PCFB College Sim Draft, giving us the first look at who the computer projects as this year’s top first-round prospects. While our Premier Madden League draft will undoubtedly play out differently — with user scouting, team needs, and combine results all factoring into the real selections — this sim draft gives us a fascinating early preview of the talent expected to headline the upcoming class.
The computer-generated order offers a neutral, performance-based glimpse at which college stars impressed most and who may be rising up draft boards. Let’s take a look at the first-round class, organized by position, and break down what makes each of these players intriguing prospects as they prepare to make the leap to the pros.
🧠 Quarterbacks
John Mateer, QB, Oklahoma
Mateer has been a steady leader for the Sooners, combining poise and accuracy with underrated mobility. He’s known for his quick decision-making and ability to extend plays, making him an intriguing mid-round quarterback prospect who could rise with a strong pre-draft showing.
Drew Allar, QB, Penn State
Allar’s physical tools are exactly what scouts drool over — a 6’5 frame, big arm, and the confidence to attack any window. His consistency took a major leap this season, and he’s viewed as a polished, pro-ready passer who can command an offense from day one. Easily one of the most NFL-ready signal callers in this class.
🏃♂️ Running Backs
Jeremiyah Love, RB, Notre Dame
Love’s blend of vision, acceleration, and toughness make him one of the most complete backs in this class. He’s a natural fit for any zone-heavy scheme and offers legitimate three-down potential thanks to his reliable hands out of the backfield.
Nicholas Singleton, RB, Penn State
A home-run hitter every time he touches the ball, Singleton brings elite speed and power to the table. He’s the kind of back that can flip field position instantly and has drawn comparisons to some of the NFL’s premier big-play runners.
Kaytron Allen, RB, Penn State
While Singleton grabs headlines, Allen is the thunder to his lightning — a physical, downhill runner who punishes defenders in short yardage. His balance and consistency between the tackles make him a reliable every-down back with pro durability.
🧱 Offensive Linemen
Kayden Proctor, LT, Alabama
Proctor is the definition of a franchise left tackle — massive, athletic, and technically sound. His combination of power and footwork make him one of the safest first-round offensive linemen in recent memory, and his experience in the SEC only adds to his résumé.
Francis Mauigoa, RT, Miami
A dominant presence on the right side, Mauigoa plays with intensity and leverage. He has the kind of physicality and finish coaches love, projecting as an early starter who can anchor the run game and keep the quarterback clean.
Spencer Fano, RT, Utah
Fano is a versatile tackle prospect with fluid movement and excellent pass protection skills. Utah’s offense thrived behind his consistency, and he’s viewed as a technically refined lineman who can play either side of the line if needed.
Jaeden Roberts, RG, Alabama
Roberts brings championship pedigree and raw power from the heart of Alabama’s offensive line. He’s a mauler in the run game who thrives in gap schemes, with the flexibility to slide inside at either guard spot.
Olaivavega Ioane, G, Penn State
Ioane is a road-grader who plays with a nasty streak and relentless motor. His leverage and upper-body strength make him difficult to move, and his steady improvement has pushed him into the first-round conversation.
Armaj Reed-Adams, G, Texas A&M
At 6’4 and over 320 pounds, Reed-Adams is an imposing figure who dominated SEC interior linemen. He’s a tone-setter who can open lanes in the run game and provide strong interior protection.
Jake Slaughter, C, Florida
Slaughter’s intelligence and leadership have been the backbone of Florida’s offensive success. He excels with line calls and technique, and his quick hands and balance make him an ideal fit for a zone-blocking system.
💪 Defensive Linemen
Tim Keenan, DT, Alabama
A space-eater with deceptive agility, Keenan anchors the Crimson Tide’s front with power and awareness. He controls gaps effectively and projects as a plug-and-play nose tackle at the next level.
Dontay Corleone, DT, Cincinnati
Nicknamed “The Godfather,” Corleone is pure disruption in the middle. His quick first step and violent hands allow him to collapse pockets and create chaos, making him a likely Day 1 starter in a 4–3 front.
Peter Woods, DT, Clemson
Woods brings elite burst and relentless pursuit from the interior. His blend of speed and strength gives him the versatility to play across the defensive line, and he’s consistently drawn comparisons to top-tier NFL defensive tackles.
🔥 Edge Rushers
Keldric Faulk, EDGE, Auburn
Faulk’s combination of length and explosion makes him one of the most dangerous pass rushers in this class. He’s shown steady growth each season and now projects as a double-digit sack threat at the next level.
David Bailey, EDGE, Texas Tech
Bailey’s high motor and relentless effort define his game. He’s not just a pass-rusher — he’s a disciplined edge defender who holds up well against the run, giving him three-down potential for any defensive scheme.
🧷 Linebackers
Gabe Jacas, LB, Illinois
Jacas is a classic off-ball linebacker who thrives in space. His instincts and sideline-to-sideline range make him a tackling machine, and his football IQ should translate quickly to the pros.
Suntarine Perkins, LB, Ole Miss
Perkins is an explosive athlete with elite closing speed. He’s a difference-maker in coverage and a weapon on blitzes, the type of linebacker modern defenses are built around.
Kyle Louis, LB, Pittsburgh
Louis brings a steady, veteran-like presence to the linebacker unit. He diagnoses plays quickly and wraps up reliably — a true leader on the field with excellent fundamentals.
Jason Henderson, MLB, Old Dominion
One of the most productive tacklers in college football, Henderson has been a stat-sheet monster. His instincts, pursuit, and leadership have earned him high praise from scouts, projecting him as a plug-and-play inside linebacker.
Anthony Hill Jr., MLB, Texas
Hill is the prototype modern inside linebacker — fast, aggressive, and versatile. He can stuff the run, drop into coverage, and rush the passer, giving him one of the highest ceilings in the class.
🛡️ Defensive Backs
Chandler Rivers, CB, Duke
Rivers is a technically sound corner who thrives in man coverage. He’s smooth in transition, physical at the catch point, and has a knack for taking away opposing WR1s.
D’Angelo Ponds, CB, Indiana
Ponds’ ball skills and anticipation make him a dangerous playmaker on the outside. He’s quick to jump routes and has the closing speed to turn near-completions into breakups.
Jermod McCoy, CB, Tennessee
McCoy is an instinctive defensive back with sticky coverage skills. His length and recovery speed make him effective against deep threats, and he’s shown excellent tackling ability in run support.
Caleb Downs, S, Ohio State
Downs is a household name — a former five-star who’s lived up to every ounce of hype. His awareness, tackling, and leadership make him a defensive quarterback and one of the safest prospects in the class.
Dillon Thieneman, S, Oregon
Thieneman is an athletic, rangy safety who plays with high energy. He covers ground effortlessly and can be used interchangeably in the slot, deep zone, or box, making him a versatile chess piece for any defense.
🎯 Tight Ends
Tanner Koziol, TE, Houston
Koziol is a reliable receiving tight end with great body control and red zone awareness. His ability to find soft spots in coverage and make contested catches makes him a chain-moving weapon in any passing attack.
Eli Stowers, TE, Vanderbilt
Stowers is a converted quarterback who brings intelligence and athleticism to the position. His size and catch radius give him matchup advantages, and his blocking has developed steadily, rounding out his game.
🎯 Wide Receivers
Jordyn Tyson, WR, Arizona State
Tyson is a dynamic slot weapon with elite burst and route-running. He creates separation with ease and can take short passes the distance thanks to his acceleration and vision in the open field.
Elijah Sarratt, WR, Indiana
Sarratt is a physical, boundary receiver who wins with body control and toughness. He’s dependable on third downs and in contested catch situations, making him a quarterback’s best friend.
Devonte Ross, WR, Penn State
Ross brings a blend of speed and savvy route-running that fits perfectly in modern spread offenses. He’s shown consistent production against top competition and could develop into a high-volume receiver at the next level.
🏁 Final Thoughts
The college sim’s first-round results give us a snapshot of balance and depth across this year’s class. Penn State dominated representation, sending a staggering five players into the simulated first round, while Alabama and other powerhouse programs showed their usual depth of NFL-ready talent.
Offensive line and defensive line prospects lead the way — always a sign of strong trench play dominating college football. The quarterback class, while smaller in number, offers intriguing potential in Drew Allar and John Mateer, and the defensive depth at linebacker and safety looks as strong as it’s been in years.
As we move closer to the Premier Madden League draft, expect the board to look much different — users will value different traits, team needs will shift priorities, and combine performances will shake everything up. But if the college sim is any indication, this year’s draft pool is loaded from top to bottom with future stars ready to make an impact.
