Colts Push to 5–1 With Gritty 44–33 Win Over Commanders, Roll Into Bye on a High Note

The Indianapolis Colts have been one of the most disciplined teams in the Premier Madden League this season, and Sunday’s 44–33 victory over the Washington Commanders only reinforced that identity. Though the game was tighter than the final score suggests, Indianapolis leaned on its usual winning formula—ball control, and dynamic quarterback play—to secure its fifth win of the season heading into a crucial early-season bye.

A Back-and-Forth Battle That Broke Late

The Commanders pushed Indianapolis harder than most teams have this season, outgaining the Colts in yardage and forcing them into a higher-tempo game than they typically like. But what the Colts surrendered in total yards, they made up for where it mattered most: situational execution.

Indianapolis once again dominated time of possession, controlling the ball for 23:48 to Washington’s 16:12. They didn’t turn the ball over offensively, and they generated the one key interception that swung momentum in their favor. They ran for 138 yards as a team, grinding down Washington’s aggressive defense with a blend of power, speed, and well-timed option looks.

That combination—along with a first-half play that will live in Colts lore—proved too much for the Commanders to overcome.

Anthony Richardson: Flawless Through the Air, Deadly on the Ground

Anthony Richardson continues to play like a cheat code wrapped in an MVP résumé.

Against a Commanders squad known for its physical man-coverage looks and blitz-heavy pressure packages, Richardson delivered a perfect passing performance:
17-for-17, 300 yards, 1 touchdown, 0 interceptions.

Washington sent heat, mixed coverages, and tried to trap Indianapolis in long-yardage situations, but Richardson’s composure never wavered. Whether it was hitting hot reads, firing lasers into tight windows, or extending plays with his legs, he controlled the game with poise.

And those legs? They weren’t just a secondary option—they were a sledgehammer. Richardson added 99 rushing yards and 3 rushing touchdowns, repeatedly punishing Washington for vacating lanes in their blitz packages. His athleticism forced the Commanders to defend every blade of grass, and frankly, they couldn’t.

Jonathan Taylor: Quiet on the Ground, Explosive Through the Air

Jonathan Taylor didn’t put up his usual rushing numbers—just 42 yards on the ground—but the Colts unlocked him as a mismatch weapon in the passing game. Taylor caught 5 passes for 99 yards and a score, gashing linebackers and safeties who had no chance matching his acceleration in space.

His receiving touchdown sparked one of the Colts’ most crucial scoring drives, and it further cemented how dangerous this offense becomes when Taylor is featured on angle routes, screens, and option concepts.

Big Plays From the Receiving Corps

Adonai Mitchell continues to emerge as a reliable downfield threat, posting 3 receptions for 89 yards. Anthony Gould contributed two catches for 64 yards, including the dagger—a 51-yard catch late in the fourth quarter that effectively iced the game. In a move that speaks to the team-first culture in Indianapolis, Gould slid down instead of scoring, allowing the Colts to burn clock and remove any remaining doubt.

Defense Steps Up When It Matters

The Colts did surrender more yards than usual, but their defense came alive in the key moments.

  • JT Tuimoloau was a terror in the trenches, delivering 2 tackles for loss and 1.5 sacks, constantly collapsing pockets and forcing hurried throws.
  • Isaiah Bolden, typically known for his speed and coverage ability, came flying in for his first sack of the year, surprising Washington with a perfectly timed corner blitz.
  • And then… the play of the game.

Domani Jackson’s 104-Yard Shockwave

Rookie sensation Domani Jackson continues to look like the defensive steal of the league.

With the first half ticking away and Washington threatening to cut into the lead heading into the locker room, Jackson jumped a route in the end zone, snatched the ball cleanly, and then ignited one of the craziest individual efforts of the season.
104 yards later, as time expired, he was celebrating in the opposite end zone with teammates mobbing him. The pick-six turned a potential Washington lead into a sudden swing in Indianapolis’ favor—a true game-changing moment.

It was the type of play elite teams build their seasons on.

Special Teams: Hidden Yardage, Huge Impact

Isaiah Bolden and Eugene Wilson turned special teams into a weapon. Both players recorded over 45 kick return yards, with long returns of 34 and 30 yards respectively. Those returns didn’t just look good—they set up the Colts with short fields and favorable drives that helped tilt the game.

In a matchup where momentum and field position mattered, those hidden yards were massive.

Onto the Bye: Rest, Reset, and Prepare for Baltimore

At 5–1, the Colts enter their bye week in prime position. They’re playing disciplined football, their young stars are blossoming, and their franchise quarterback is performing at an MVP level. But the bye comes at the perfect time—Indianapolis needs a chance to get healthy and tighten up the defensive issues that surfaced against Washington.

That’s crucial, because waiting on the other side is a showdown with one of the AFC’s elite: the Baltimore Ravens.

A battle of heavyweights. A chance to validate the Colts’ early dominance. And perhaps, a preview of a postseason clash.

For now, though, the Colts can savor a gritty win, a 5–1 record, and a team that looks more dangerous with every passing week.